Why Did the U.S. Ban Gold Ownership? Executive Order 6102 Explained

Published

· Last updated

Stacked gold bullion bars

Executive Order 6102 was the order that made it illegal for most U.S. residents to hold gold coins, gold bullion and gold certificates. President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed it on April 5, 1933, in the depths of the Great Depression, and it required people to turn their gold in to the Federal Reserve by May 1, 1933. This guide explains why the U.S. banned gold ownership, what the order required, how it was enforced, and when private citizens were finally allowed to own gold again.

The short answer: the government said it was stopping gold hoarding that was draining the banking system. By collecting private gold, it could support more paper currency and, a few months later, raise the official price of gold. Private ownership of most gold stayed illegal until December 31, 1974.

What was the purpose of Executive Order 6102?

Roosevelt framed the order as a way to end hoarding, meaning the withdrawal of gold from ordinary channels of trade, which he argued was undermining the banking system. By early 1933, the U.S. banking system was in crisis, and a national banking holiday in March had preceded the order. The Federal Reserve’s gold reserves had been drained by hoarding at home and by gold flowing out of the country.

There was a second, more technical motive. The Federal Reserve was required to back its notes with gold, and it was near the 40 percent gold-backing floor at the time. Collecting gold from the public gave the central bank room to issue more currency. In other words, the order was about both confidence in the banks and the mechanics of the money supply.

What did the FDR order actually require?

The order relied on Section 5(b) of the Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917, as amended by the emergency banking act of March 9, 1933, and cited a declared national emergency. Its main requirements were straightforward:

  • Gold coin, gold bullion and gold certificates had to be delivered to a Federal Reserve Bank or a member bank by May 1, 1933.
  • Gold acquired after April 28 had to be delivered within three days.
  • Holders were paid in other U.S. coin or currency at the official price of $20.67 per troy ounce.
  • A willful violation carried a fine of up to $10,000, up to 10 years in prison, or both.

The order was not a total ban. It allowed several exemptions: gold used for industrial, professional or artistic purposes, up to $100 in gold coin and certificates per person, coins with special value to collectors, gold held for foreign governments, foreign central banks and the Bank for International Settlements, and transactions made under license.

How many people actually turned in their gold?

Estimates put compliance at roughly 20 to 25 percent of the privately held gold. One source, citing the economists Milton Friedman and Anna Schwartz, gives that range, and another puts it at about 25 percent of gold coins. There is no reliable official total for how much gold was collected, and we have left out the figures in circulation that we could not verify with two sources.

What happened to the price of gold after the order?

The order paid holders the old fixed price of $20.67 per ounce. Then came the Gold Reserve Act, signed on January 30, 1934, which moved the official price from $20.67 to $35 an ounce. A proclamation on January 31, 1934 fixed the dollar’s value at $35 per ounce. The Act also created the Exchange Stabilization Fund. The change raised the official price by about 69 percent, which meant the government’s gold holdings were suddenly worth far more in dollars than what it had paid the public for them.

Another step came earlier. On June 5, 1933, a congressional resolution voided gold clauses in public and private contracts, which had promised repayment in gold. The Supreme Court took up the issue in three cases decided in 1935: Norman v. Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, Nortz v. United States and Perry v. United States. The Court sustained the government’s monetary actions overall. In Nortz, a holder of gold certificates who had surrendered them recovered only nominal damages, and in Perry, the gold clause in federal bonds was ruled binding but the holder also received only nominal damages.

Was Executive Order 6102 constitutional?

The 1935 gold clause cases are the closest the Supreme Court came to settling the question, and they ended with the government’s monetary program largely intact. We could not read the opinions themselves in full, so we describe only what secondary sources report: the Court sustained the government’s actions overall, although individual holders received little compensation. If you are researching the legal question in depth, the case texts are the place to start.

Is Executive Order 6102 still in effect?

No. U.S. residents may own, buy and sell gold today. Congress passed Public Law 93-373, which President Gerald Ford signed on August 14, 1974, allowing private ownership of gold as of December 31, 1974. Executive Order 11825, dated December 31, 1974, revoked the remaining gold-regulating orders. Sources differ on whether Executive Order 6102 was repealed by name or simply superseded by later orders, so the safest summary is that the ban on private gold ownership ended on December 31, 1974. Gold is not U.S. legal tender, but it is legal to hold.

What is the 1933 Double Eagle?

One of the most famous side effects of the gold recall is the 1933 Double Eagle. About 445,500 twenty-dollar gold coins were minted with the 1933 date, but none were officially released because of the gold recall and Roosevelt’s 1933 orders. A single coin that had belonged to King Farouk of Egypt sold on July 30, 2002 for $7.59 million. The government kept ten coins that were found by the Langbord family, an appeals court ruled for the government in August 2016, and the Supreme Court declined to review the case in April 2017.

Frequently asked questions

What was Executive Order 6102?

An order signed by President Roosevelt on April 5, 1933, that required most gold coin, bullion and certificates to be handed over to the Federal Reserve by May 1, 1933.

What was the penalty for keeping gold?

A willful violation carried a fine of up to $10,000, up to 10 years in prison, or both.

When could U.S. residents own gold again?

Private ownership was legalized as of December 31, 1974, under a law signed by President Ford on August 14, 1974.

If you enjoy explainers like this, browse more in our History section and subscribe to Mr Global Rankss on YouTube for more science, history and rankings.

Related reading: how early American banks verified your identity and who invented Monopoly.

Response

  1. […] Related reading: USS Cyclops: What Happened to the Navy Ship That Vanished in 1918, Marine Corps Birthday: How the U.S. Marines Were Founded in 1775 and Why Did the U.S. Ban Gold Ownership? Executive Order 6102 Explained. […]

    Like

Leave a Reply