How Did People Deal With Wisdom Teeth Before Dentistry? Toothache, Extraction and Early Anesthesia

Published

· Last updated

Orange dental chair and equipment in a bright modern dental office

Before dentistry and anesthesia, people with a bad wisdom tooth either endured the pain or had the tooth pulled by a barber-surgeon or a traveling tooth puller, using metal hooks and levers, with no effective painkiller until the mid-1800s. No source we found describes wisdom teeth specifically in that era, so this guide covers toothache and extraction in general, which is what any painful back tooth would have meant.

Wisdom teeth are the last molars and the hardest to reach, so it is fair to ask what happened when one went wrong centuries ago. The short answer is that the options were grim. This article explains who did the work, what tools they used, which remedies people tried first, what could go wrong, and how anesthesia finally changed everything. We also say plainly where the historical evidence runs out.

Key facts at a glance

  • A Neanderthal from Krapina, Croatia, about 130,000 years old, had a displaced wisdom tooth and may have tried to relieve the pain with a toothpick-like tool.
  • For centuries, barber-surgeons and traveling operators pulled teeth.
  • The pelican, a hook-and-lever tool, dates from about the 1300s. The toothkey replaced it in the 1700s.
  • Effective anesthesia reached tooth pulling only in the mid-1800s.
  • The world’s first dental school opened in Baltimore in 1840.
  • Today, current UK guidance says healthy wisdom teeth should not be removed routinely.

Did ancient people have trouble with wisdom teeth?

Yes, at least some did. Researchers led by David Frayer of the University of Kansas studied a Neanderthal from Krapina, Croatia, about 130,000 years old. A lower wisdom tooth and a neighboring premolar had been pushed out of position, and grooves and scratches on the teeth suggest the individual poked something into the mouth, perhaps to ease the pain. The authors stress that this is their interpretation of a single individual (University of Kansas; ScienceDaily).

Why do wisdom teeth get stuck?

A popular idea is that softer, cooked food after farming began about 12,000 years ago meant less chewing, so jaws grew smaller while teeth stayed the same size. Researchers present this tentatively. One 2011 study compared skulls from 11 populations and found that hunter-gatherers had longer, narrower jaws, but it did not test wisdom teeth directly. National Geographic notes that scientists still debate whether smaller jaws are an evolutionary adaptation or a response to less chewing, and that genetics also matters (Live Science; National Geographic).

Who pulled teeth before dentists?

Barbers did, and they were not alone. In medieval and early modern Europe, barber-surgeons routinely pulled teeth alongside bloodletting and minor surgery, and they learned the trade as apprentices. Art UK says they were the main source of dental care until the mid-1700s (Encyclopedia.com; Newcastle University; Art UK; Medical University of South Carolina).

Traveling operators also took part. Stony Brook University’s dental exhibit says that before the 19th century extractions were done by surgeons or by charlatans, sometimes as street performance, and the Science Museum Group says tooth pulling was carried out by barber-surgeons and traveling practitioners (Stony Brook University; Science Museum Group).

What tools did they use?

The pelican. Named for its resemblance to a bird’s beak, it had a claw that hooked over the tooth and a curved bolster that rested on the gum as a pivot. Levering pulled the tooth out sideways. The Science Museum Group believes the design dates from the 1300s, Stony Brook credits the surgeon Guy de Chauliac with an early mention, and both warn that it could damage neighboring teeth, gums or the jaw. It remained in use into the early 1800s (Science Museum Group; Stony Brook University; Medical University of South Carolina).

The toothkey. This tool had a hinged hook, a bolster against the gum and a handle that was turned like a door key. It was widely used from the early to mid-1700s into the 1800s. It often broke teeth and left the roots behind, and it could bruise gums or even break a piece of the jaw. Forceps gradually replaced it in the 19th century (Stony Brook University; Encyclopedia.com; CBC News).

One caution: no source says these tools were made for wisdom teeth, so we do not claim that. Any statement about how hard a back tooth would have been to pull with them is our inference, not a documented fact.

Did pulling a tooth hurt?

Very much. Historian Colin Jones of Queen Mary University of London says anesthetic only came in around the middle of the 19th century, and the Science Museum Group describes pulling as painful and as the only cure for a diseased tooth. Historian Lindsey Fitzharris calls extraction before anesthetics extremely painful (CBC News; Science Museum Group; Collectors Weekly).

What did people try instead of pulling?

For thousands of years many cultures blamed toothache on a worm gnawing the tooth. The Canadian Museum of Health Care says the belief ran from about 1800 BCE into the 18th century. Remedies included burning henbane seed or wax and inhaling the smoke to drive the worm out, and henbane is poisonous. Fitzharris adds that henbane is a mild narcotic, so it may have given brief relief (Museum of Health Care; The Collector; Collectors Weekly).

Heat was another approach. Hot irons or heated needles were applied to painful teeth, and the 11th-century physician al-Zahrawi recommended a hot iron in tooth holes. In India, a text from about 650 CE describes putting wax in a cavity and burning it with a hot probe. Surgeons even cauterized the mouth of Louis XIV to treat an infection, though that was not a wisdom tooth case (The Collector; Museum of Health Care; CBC News).

Did clove oil work?

Clove oil was a long-lived remedy. The Wood Library-Museum of Anesthesiology says a 1754 textbook recommended it for hollow, aching teeth and that dentists still used it into the 1940s, although it is no longer considered effective for tooth pain. The Museum of Health Care notes that some traditional dentists still use it (Wood Library-Museum; Museum of Health Care).

Could a bad tooth kill you?

An infection that began in a lower molar could. Ludwig’s angina is a rapidly spreading infection of the floor of the mouth and neck, and about 90 percent of adult cases start from a tooth, usually a lower molar. Before antibiotics, roughly half or more of untreated cases were fatal, mainly because the airway became blocked, compared with under about 8 percent with modern treatment (Life in the Fast Lane; 5-Minute Emergency Consult). These are modern medical figures, not historical death counts, and we found no source counting deaths from wisdom teeth specifically.

How did anesthesia change tooth pulling?

Two dentists drove the change. In December 1844 the Hartford dentist Horace Wells watched a laughing-gas show, and the next day a colleague, John Riggs, pulled one of Wells’s own wisdom teeth while Wells breathed nitrous oxide. Wells reported feeling no pain. His January 1845 demonstration at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston failed when the patient seemed to cry out, and Wells was ridiculed (Connecticut History; Fauchard Academy; Britannica).

On October 16, 1846, the Boston dentist William Morton gave ether to a patient at the same hospital during surgery to remove a neck tumor. It worked, and it is widely treated as the first successful public demonstration of surgical anesthesia. Crawford Long, a Georgia physician, had used ether in 1842 but did not publicize it (Britannica; Linda Hall Library; Science Museum Group). A later step, hypodermic cocaine in 1884, began the modern era of dental anesthesia (Wood Library-Museum; Encyclopedia.com).

When did dentistry become a profession?

The Baltimore College of Dental Surgery opened in 1840, founded by Horace Hayden and Chapin Harris. The University of Maryland and the American Dental Association both describe it as the world’s first dental college (University of Maryland; American Dental Association).

How are wisdom teeth handled today?

With anesthesia, and only when there is a reason. UK guidance issued in 2000 says wisdom teeth with no disease should not be removed routinely, with surgery limited to problems such as untreatable decay, infection or damage to neighboring teeth. Some dental surgeons dispute this and argue that retained impacted teeth can cause decay and gum infection (NICE; Royal College of Surgeons; British Dental Journal). Talk to a dentist about your own teeth.

Frequently asked questions

How were teeth pulled before modern dentistry?

With hooks and levers such as the pelican from about the 1300s and the toothkey in the 1700s and 1800s, later replaced by forceps, and without effective anesthesia.

Did people die from wisdom teeth?

We found no source documenting deaths from wisdom teeth specifically. Dental infections in general could spread to the neck and become life-threatening before antibiotics.

What did people do for toothache besides pulling the tooth?

They used henbane smoke against the supposed tooth worm, hot-iron cautery and clove oil, among other remedies.

When did painless tooth pulling begin?

Horace Wells had a wisdom tooth pulled under nitrous oxide in December 1844, and William Morton’s ether demonstration succeeded in October 1846.

Did ancient people have impacted wisdom teeth?

At least some did. A 130,000-year-old Neanderthal from Krapina had a displaced wisdom tooth. How common impaction was in the past is not known.

Want more stories about how people lived in the past? Watch the Mr Global Rankss YouTube channel for new history and science videos.

Leave a Reply