Why did Queen Elizabeth have black teeth?

Published

· Last updated

Two half-timbered Tudor dormer windows and tall stone chimneys on a stone roofline under a grey sky

Queen Elizabeth I is said to have had black teeth in old age, and the best-supported explanation is decay from a diet rich in sugar, an expensive luxury at the Tudor court. This article is about Elizabeth I, who reigned from 1558 to 1603, and not Elizabeth II. The evidence is thinner than the legend suggests. It rests on a handful of descriptions from the last years of her reign, and those descriptions do not agree on colour. The sections below set out what each source says, where independent sources support one another, and which popular claims the evidence does not support.

What did eyewitnesses say about her teeth?

The best-known description comes from Paul Hentzner, a German lawyer who watched the queen process to chapel at Greenwich in 1598. His journal, published in English as Travels in England during the Reign of Queen Elizabeth, describes her in her sixty-fifth year, as he was told, with narrow lips and black teeth, and adds that this was a defect the English seemed subject to from their too great use of sugar. History Revealed quotes the same passage and dates the visit to 1598. Hentzner was a foreign visitor, and the sugar explanation is his own opinion and not a medical finding.

A second account comes from the French ambassador, André Hurault, sieur de Maisse, who had an audience with the queen on 8 December 1597, when she was 64. In the translation of his journal reproduced by the Tudor History site, he calls her teeth very yellow and unequal compared with what they had been formerly, so he was told, and says the left side was in worse condition than the right. The Canadian Dental Association’s 2024 feature on famous teeth and Science Insights both repeat the description of very yellow and unequal teeth. The two accounts differ on colour, and the evidence does not show whether the difference lies in the teeth or in the observers. Karen Preston, writing in an early modern oral health essay hosted by the University of Victoria and citing Royal Museums Greenwich, states that the queen’s teeth were eventually black with decay.

A stone tower of Windsor Castle rising above a walled rose garden under a partly cloudy sky
Illustration only: Windsor Castle, a royal residence of the Tudor era, not the site of the 1597 or 1598 audiences.

Two historians quoted by History Revealed, Karen Hearn and Helen Hackett, add a caution. They argue that the later image of a grotesque old Elizabeth was shaped by nineteenth and twentieth century painters and writers, and that it reflects attitudes toward ageing women as much as evidence. That is a reason to read the 1597 and 1598 accounts as individual observations and not as a full medical record.

Why would sugar have blackened her teeth?

Sugar feeds bacteria in the mouth, and their acid wears away tooth enamel. Once enamel is breached, decay spreads into the softer tissue beneath, and gum disease can follow and loosen teeth. Science Insights gives this as the main explanation for the queen’s dark, rotting teeth, and Preston attributes her poor teeth to the sugar available to the nobility, including elaborate dessert buffets at feasts.

Sugar was not an everyday food in sixteenth-century England. The Canadian Dental Association feature describes cane sugar as an expensive imported good among the wealthy during her reign, priced roughly like Asian spices. Historic UK likewise calls sugar expensive and largely confined to the aristocracy, and names Elizabeth as one of the period’s most famous sugar lovers. A court that ate sweetmeats freely, and a queen who could afford them, would have been unusually exposed to the damage.

Was she unusual among the English?

Hentzner himself did not treat the queen’s teeth as unique. He called black teeth a defect the English seemed subject to, and Preston writes that decay became a prevalent health issue as sugary foods spread. The difference was that a monarch was watched, described and painted, while the mouths of ordinary people were not. Her teeth are recorded because of who she was, and not necessarily because they were worse than those around her.

Did Tudors blacken their teeth on purpose?

A popular story says that black teeth became a status symbol and that some people darkened their own. Historic UK repeats this and says some people deliberately rotted their teeth. The Canadian Dental Association feature says black teeth became a symbol of wealth and that working-class people artificially blackened their teeth to appear better off, and Preston, citing Royal Museums Greenwich, says it became fashionable for some women to darken their teeth. Science Insights, however, calls the idea believable because of sugar’s link to wealth but says there is little firm evidence from the period. None of the summaries reviewed names a Tudor document describing the practice, and none says Elizabeth darkened her own teeth on purpose. This article therefore treats deliberate blackening as a repeated claim and not an established fact. What the evidence supports is narrower: sugar was a status food, and heavy sugar eating damaged teeth.

What happened when the queen had a toothache?

The queen’s own pain is better documented than her appearance. In 1578 she suffered a severe toothache that kept her awake for nights, and her councillors urged her to have the tooth pulled, but she was afraid. The Elizabeth Files, drawing on John Strype’s life of Bishop John Aylmer, and the Tudor Society both tell the same story: Aylmer, the Bishop of London, had a surgeon draw one of his own teeth to show her that the procedure was simple. Chalmers’ General Biographical Dictionary, which also credits Strype, records him telling the tooth-drawer that although he was an old man with few teeth to spare, he should draw this one for him. Seeing him unafraid, the queen agreed to the extraction. The Tudor Society cites no source itself, which leaves Strype as the underlying authority.

Timber-framed gables with leaded windows and a brick chimney against a cloudy sky
Illustration only: Tudor-style timber-framed gables, not a place tied to the 1578 episode.

For a wider look at early tooth removal, see how people dealt with wisdom teeth before dentistry. The practices that followed in later centuries are covered in our guide to brushing teeth in the 1800s, and Tudor washing habits more broadly are covered in our look at bathing in the 1500s.

What does the evidence not show?

Several claims about the queen’s teeth appear online but rest on a single source or on sources that conflict, and they are left out of this article. They include specific numbers of teeth lost, claims about homemade tooth rubs, assertions that lead-based cosmetics caused the blackening, and comparisons with the teeth of other Tudor figures. The evidence for the central point is stronger than for any of these. Two independent descriptions from the late 1590s, one by Hentzner and one by de Maisse, show a mouth in poor condition, and several modern summaries tie the damage to sugar. It remains limited. Both accounts come from the queen’s last years, neither is a medical examination, and de Maisse reports the earlier condition of her teeth only at second hand.

Frequently asked questions

Did Queen Elizabeth I really have black teeth?

According to Paul Hentzner, who saw her in 1598, yes. The French ambassador de Maisse described them in 1597 as very yellow and unequal instead, and the two accounts agree that her teeth were in poor condition.

What caused her teeth to turn black?

Decay, most likely from heavy sugar consumption. Sugar feeds mouth bacteria, whose acid erodes enamel, and gum disease can add to the damage.

Did people blacken their teeth to copy her?

Several modern summaries say black teeth became a status symbol and that some people darkened their own, but another source finds little firm evidence from the period, and none says Elizabeth did it on purpose. It remains an unproven claim and not a fact about the period.

Did Elizabeth I have a tooth pulled?

In 1578 she suffered a severe toothache. Accounts based on John Strype say Bishop John Aylmer had one of his own teeth pulled to persuade her to accept extraction, and she agreed.

Did Queen Elizabeth II have black teeth?

No source reviewed says so. The black teeth story concerns Elizabeth I, who reigned from 1558 to 1603.

The surviving evidence cannot show every detail of the queen’s mouth, but it consistently points to sugar and decay, and the sources below show where each claim comes from.

Related reading: How Did People Brush Their Teeth in the 1800s?, How Did People Deal With Wisdom Teeth Before Dentistry? and How Did People in the 1500s Shower?

Leave a Reply